peyton is definitely the better manning the only thing you can bring up is that eli got a superbowl victory quicker but that doesnt mean he's better their is alot of factors that helped eli get a superbowl victory before peyton like the defense the giants had and still have except for strahan and osi cause of injuries but you look at peytons stats 4,000 yards every season of his career but 2 and peyton is having one of his worst seasons throwing a int for every td he throws but you look at his stats he has thrown double the td's compared to interceptions as for eli he almost matches interceptions with td's but last year in the post season eli matured into one of the great qbs in this league but peyton is off this season so far and eli is having the better season this year but overall peyton is the man-ning.

Pete I saw that poll on espn and it was 77% Peyton and 23% Eli, and I just dont trust Eli yet he had a great stretch of 7 or 8 games but I think he could easily fall into his old bad habits