Raul Ibanzez, Shane Victoriano, Jorge Posada, Mike Mussina, Russ Martin, JJ Hardy.

its soo hard to be over rated, underated in baseball. if you are doing well, you get noticed..if you are struggling you get noticed..people have slumps, people get hot and you cant judge if they are overrated underated by slumps..and people are only put in the game for certain things, situations, so its hard to see who is over rated. but if i was forced to pick someone, i would say miquel caberea, jose reyes

I think David Eckstien is really underrated. The guy is like 5 foot tall, and near 110 pounds, and still plays the game as good as anybody. If not David Eckstein then i'm gonna go with Carlos lee with the Brewers. He's finally getting recognition after signing a decent contract with them.