Yeah, this is a toughy. By "better 07 season" I will assume you mean better stats(passing yards, passing TD's). I would have to go with Manning because of the inexperienced backfield that the
Colts are playing with this year. Manning is going to have to throw more than Brady. With 7 total years experience between the Colt's four running backs, the
Colts are going to have to rely more on the passing game. The Pats do have more tools, with more experience and will be more effective on the ground than the
Colts.