I am not a big believer in either but I favor Giambi. Has the short porch in right field, is improving in the field, and isn't the only lefty power hitter on his club. And to say either one is a leader is wrong. If anything Giambi shouldn't be considered a leader, Derek Jeter's job, Delgado should be much more vocal in his approach to his young teammates who lose focus on a regular basis. In that aspect he fails.

I hate both players, but I think I would rather have Giambi. First of all, he plays in the AL where he can play DH a little. Also, I respect him more. Although, he lied to Baseball about steroids, He never denounced our country. When Delgado was a Blue Jay, He refused to stand for the National Anthem. He seems to have forgot who gave him the opportunity to live in the greatest country and give him a few million dollars a year.

i would take jason giambi without a doubt. he is playing better with the mustache and you dont hear him talking junk u just hear him addmiting his wrong doings

I would say delgado, because not only is he a great team player, but you never see him get angry at himself and pout, he always works 110 percent and he pushes his teammates to be their best. I would have a role player like Delgado on my team any day.

Carlos Delgado is a much better player than Giambi since Jason is off the Juice. Carlos is coming off of surgery, He will start to hit as soon as the weather warms up. OH BOY WAS I RIGHT