well all i have to say is that the players voted on this.....i guess they're jealous of all the rings jeter has......arod and david wright were both in the top 5 as well...i think kevin youkiliss is in the top 5 too....jeter is possibly the most clutch hitter in the playoffs of all time...i hate the yankees with a passion but i eve have to disagree with it.....i would love to know if the players would of still voted for these guys if they had to actually reveal their names instead of being anonymous

NO WAY HE IS ONE OF THE BEST SHORT STOPS OF ALL TIME THE PLAYS JETER MAKES DIVING IN THE STANDS ARE AMAZING AND HE'S A CLUTCH HITTER HE'S A GREAT PLAYER YOU DONT SEE HIM PLAYING AS WELL AS HE USED TO LATELY HE'S STILL GOOD THOUGH BUT HES BEEN AROUND FOR A WHILE BUT HES DEFINITELY ONE OF THE BEST OF ALL TIME AT THAT POSITION.

i aint sayin it im disagreeing. I think he is the best team leader in the league. He is great defensively and is a clutch hitter.